Evaluating Drivers and Sources of Pathogens to Surface Waters in Primarily Arid and Semi-Arid Tribal Lands of the United States

190715-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
Pathogenic contamination is a significant factor contributing to the degradation of surface water both globally and within the United States. This leads to negative economic impacts, sickness, and, in severe cases, fatalities. As the world's population grows, pollution increases, placing…

Pathogenic contamination is a significant factor contributing to the degradation of surface water both globally and within the United States. This leads to negative economic impacts, sickness, and, in severe cases, fatalities. As the world's population grows, pollution increases, placing more stress on water resources, particularly in arid regions. The situation is made worse by climate change. The forecasted expansion of arid and semi-arid land areas and alterations in precipitation patterns could have a significant impact on those living in poverty and dry regions. This dissertation aims to investigate previously undocumented threats to water quality through understanding pathogen drivers in arid and semi-arid environments and documenting wastewater infrastructure on Tribal lands. Specifically, I first investigated how ephemeral streams (common in arid and semiarid areas) impact the presence of pathogens in surface waters by identifying the main drivers of E. coli concentration from a series of proposed predictors. Second, I identified unknown potential sources of water quality impairments on Tribal lands, which are mainly rural and in arid or semiarid areas, focusing on wastewater infrastructure in these systems. I specifically quantified populations served by wastewater treatment plants and then used a remote sensing approach to identify possible unpermitted wastewater lagoons that often serve as the only wastewater infrastructure in some areas. The findings revealed unique insights that could help aid water management in arid and semiarid regions as well as in rural areas.
Date Created
2023
Agent

Mechanistic Insights into Dynamic Predictions of Pathogens in Engineered Systems

187564-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
Pathogens can proliferate in the built environment and can cause disease outbreaks if water and wastewater are not properly managed. Understanding pathogens that grow in engineered systems is crucial to protecting public health and preventing disease. Using dynamic computational models…

Pathogens can proliferate in the built environment and can cause disease outbreaks if water and wastewater are not properly managed. Understanding pathogens that grow in engineered systems is crucial to protecting public health and preventing disease. Using dynamic computational models can reveal mechanistic insights into these systems to aid in understanding risk drivers and determining risk management strategies. The first research chapter of this thesis investigates tradeoffs for reducing the cost associated with Legionnaire’s Disease, hot water scalding, and energy use using a computational framework for evaluating an optimal water heater temperature set point. The model demonstrated that the optimal temperature set point was highly dependent on assumptions made regarding the dose response parameter for a common configuration of an electric water heater in a hospital setting. The optimal temperature was 55°C or 48°C for subclinical vs. clinical severity dose response, respectively, compared with current recommendations of 60°C to kill bacteria and 49°C to prevent scalding and conserve energy. The second research chapter models the population dynamics of antibiotic-susceptible Escherichia coli (E. coli) and antibiotic-resistant E. coli with a population ecology-exposure assessment model in surface water to quantify the risk of urinary tract infection from recreational swimming activities. Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) was modeled in the environment and the human gastrointestinal tract for several scenarios. HGT was generally not a dominant driver of exposure estimates compared to other factors such as growth and dilution, however, the rank order of factors was scenario-dependent. The final research chapter models pathogen transport from wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) exposures and assesses the risk to workers based on several exposure scenarios. Case studies were performed to investigate infection risk drivers across different scenarios, including adjustments for the timing of exposure and personal protective equipment. A web application was developed for use by WWTP risk managers to be used with site-specific data. The proposed modeling frameworks identified risk drivers across several microbial risk scenarios and provide flexible tools for risk managers to use when making water treatment and use decisions for water management plans used for premise plumbing as well as for wastewater treatment practices.
Date Created
2023
Agent

UNDERSTANDING AND MANAGEMENT OF HOLISTIC WATER QUALITY AND LEGIONELLA IN BUILDING WATER SYSTEMS

Description

This research aims to develop an understanding of how interventions designed to improve water quality in buildings can be used to mitigate Legionella pneumophila concentrations. Intervention methods can be described as any approach that can be used to improve microbial…

This research aims to develop an understanding of how interventions designed to improve water quality in buildings can be used to mitigate Legionella pneumophila concentrations. Intervention methods can be described as any approach that can be used to improve microbial water quality. In order to provide a foundation of background knowledge, a literature review was conducted to identify similar studies and collect relevant and timely research similar to the subject. The information gathered from the literature review was used to structure the sampling process and parameters. Using the research collected from the literature review, a review table was created to summarize the differences in the studies conducted and to determine research gaps. To categorize the studies, intervention methods, contaminants addressed, and water quality meta-data were differentiated for each of the articles. For the purpose of the sampling process, the three interventions analyzed consist of flushing, water heater set point change, and both flushing and water heater set point change. The locations of the sampling consisted of the city drinking water inlet, the basement janitor's closet, basement shower, 2nd floor, 3rd floor, and 7th floor break rooms and restrooms of the Interdisciplinary Science and Technology Building IV at ASU. For the flushing intervention, the sampling results demonstrated an increase in free and total chlorine concentration post flushing which aligns with the research found in the literature review. In addition, it was observed that iron concentrations drastically increased for both the cold and hot water by flushing. There was a significant decrease detected for ATP concentrations post flush in the hot line. However through the sampling session, the flushing intervention did not yield statistically significant results for Legionella concentrations.

Date Created
2023-05
Agent

UNDERSTANDING AND MANAGEMENT OF HOLISTIC WATER QUALITY AND LEGIONELLA IN BUILDING WATER SYSTEMS

Description

This research aims to develop an understanding of how interventions designed to improve water quality in buildings can be used to mitigate Legionella pneumophila concentrations. Intervention methods can be described as any approach that can be used to improve microbial…

This research aims to develop an understanding of how interventions designed to improve water quality in buildings can be used to mitigate Legionella pneumophila concentrations. Intervention methods can be described as any approach that can be used to improve microbial water quality. In order to provide a foundation of background knowledge, a literature review was conducted to identify similar studies and collect relevant and timely research similar to the subject. The information gathered from the literature review was used to structure the sampling process and parameters. Using the research collected from the literature review, a review table was created to summarize the differences in the studies conducted and to determine research gaps. To categorize the studies, intervention methods, contaminants addressed, and water quality meta-data were differentiated for each of the articles. For the purpose of the sampling process, the three interventions analyzed consist of flushing, water heater set point change, and both flushing and water heater set point change. The locations of the sampling consisted of the city drinking water inlet, the basement janitor's closet, basement shower, 2nd floor, 3rd floor, and 7th floor break rooms and restrooms of the Interdisciplinary Science and Technology Building IV at ASU. For the flushing intervention, the sampling results demonstrated an increase in free and total chlorine concentration post flushing which aligns with the research found in the literature review. In addition, it was observed that iron concentrations drastically increased for both the cold and hot water by flushing. There was a significant decrease detected for ATP concentrations post flush in the hot line. However through the sampling session, the flushing intervention did not yield statistically significant results for Legionella concentrations.

Date Created
2023-05
Agent

Understanding and Management of Holistic Water Quality and Legionella in Building Water Systems

Description

This research aims to develop an understanding of how interventions designed to improve water quality in buildings can be used to mitigate Legionella pneumophila concentrations. Intervention methods can be described as any approach that can be used to improve microbial…

This research aims to develop an understanding of how interventions designed to improve water quality in buildings can be used to mitigate Legionella pneumophila concentrations. Intervention methods can be described as any approach that can be used to improve microbial water quality. In order to provide a foundation of background knowledge, a literature review was conducted to identify similar studies and collect relevant and timely research similar to the subject. The information gathered from the literature review was used to structure the sampling process and parameters. Using the research collected from the literature review, a review table was created to summarize the differences in the studies conducted and to determine research gaps. To categorize the studies, intervention methods, contaminants addressed, and water quality meta-data were differentiated for each of the articles. For the purpose of the sampling process, the three interventions analyzed consist of flushing, water heater set point change, and both flushing and water heater set point change. The locations of the sampling consisted of the city drinking water inlet, the basement janitor's closet, basement shower, 2nd floor, 3rd floor, and 7th floor break rooms and restrooms of the Interdisciplinary Science and Technology Building IV at ASU. For the flushing intervention, the sampling results demonstrated an increase in free and total chlorine concentration post flushing which aligns with the research found in the literature review. In addition, it was observed that iron concentrations drastically increased for both the cold and hot water by flushing. There was a significant decrease detected for ATP concentrations post flush in the hot line. However through the sampling session, the flushing intervention did not yield statistically significant results for Legionella concentrations.

Date Created
2023-05
Agent

Assessing Biofilm Growth on Pristine and Aged Microplastics Exposed to Tempe Town Lake Water

171635-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
This study investigated the difference in biofilm growth on pristine and aged polypropylene microplastics exposed to Tempe Town Lake water for 8 weeks. The research question here is, does the aging of microplastic (MPs) change the biofilm formation rate and…

This study investigated the difference in biofilm growth on pristine and aged polypropylene microplastics exposed to Tempe Town Lake water for 8 weeks. The research question here is, does the aging of microplastic (MPs) change the biofilm formation rate and composition of the biofilm in comparison with the pristine MPs. To answer this question, the biofilm formation was quantified using different methods over time for both pristine polypropylene and aged polypropylene using agar plate counts and crystal violet staining. Colony counts based on agar plating showed an increase in microbial growth over the 8 weeks of treatment, with the aged MPs accumulating higher microbial counts than the pristine MPs. The diversity of the biofilm decreased over time for both MPs and the aged MPs had overall less diversity in biofilm, based on phenotype enumeration, in comparison with the pristine MPs. Higher biofilm growth on aged MPs was confirmed using crystal violet staining, which stains the negatively charged biological compounds such as proteins and the extracellular polymeric substance matrix of the biofilm. Using this complementary approach to colony counting, the same trend of higher biofilm growth on aged MPs was found. Further studies will focus on confirming the phenotype findings using microbiome analysis following DNA extraction. This project created a methodology to quantify biofilm formation on MPs, which was used to show that MPs may accumulate more biofilms in the environment as they age under sunlight.
Date Created
2022
Agent

Exploring Intensive Agriculture and Organic Fertilizer Management in the US: Implications for Nutrient Pollution Prevention

168288-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
Intensified food production on large farms across the world has led to discussions on how to facilitate sustainable policies and practices to reduce nutrient pollution. In Chapter 1, I evaluated the co-variability of agricultural intensification, environmental degradation, and socio-economic indicators…

Intensified food production on large farms across the world has led to discussions on how to facilitate sustainable policies and practices to reduce nutrient pollution. In Chapter 1, I evaluated the co-variability of agricultural intensification, environmental degradation, and socio-economic indicators throughout the US to explore the potential evidence for the existence of sustainable intensification of agriculture in the US. I identified distinct agro-social-eco regions in the US that provide background for future regional studies of (sustainable intensification) SI in the US and beyond. I observed regions of moderate agricultural intensity and lower environmental degradation within the Great Plains, and regions of high agricultural intensity and higher environmental degradation throughout portions of the Midwest. Insights gained from this study can provide roadmaps for improved sustainable agricultural intensification within the US. In Chapter 2, the study summarized state regulations controlling a key nutrient input - the land application of biosolids from human wastewater treatment and manures from regulated animal feeding operations. Results indicate high variability of both manure and biosolids regulations among the states and stark differences in the regulation of land application of biosolids versus manures. This work can be used to identify opportunities for the strengthening of regulatory frameworks for managing these resources with minimal risk to the environment. In Chapter 3, I combined aspects of the previous chapters to understand the potential impact of specific CAFO land application regulations on nutrient pollution and assess if stricter regulations related to better environmental outcomes. I compared TN AND TP accumulated yields in surface waters across US States with state specific CAFO land application regulations across US Policy scenario tests revealed that more restrictions were associated with higher nutrient levels, indicating reactive policy making and delayed nonpoint source pollution responses. Overall, I found that fostering adaptive capacity and management within delineated agro-social-eco regions will likely facilitate sustainable food systems in the US.
Date Created
2021
Agent

Comparative Exposure Assessment of Antibiotic Resistance Determinants in Biosolids in Fertilizer Application to Lettuce Crops

165168-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
Water is a scarce resource that is recycled through wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) to help fulfill the demand for water. Agriculture is a large consumer of water, indicating that WWTP-treated water is proportionally applied to crops at a high rate.…

Water is a scarce resource that is recycled through wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) to help fulfill the demand for water. Agriculture is a large consumer of water, indicating that WWTP-treated water is proportionally applied to crops at a high rate. Recycled water is highly regulated but is capable of containing high-risk pathogens and contaminants despite the efforts of physical and microbial treatments throughout the WWTP process. WWTPs are also producers of biosolids, treated sewage sludge regulated by the EPA that can be applied in agricultural settings to act as a fertilizer. Biosolids are a useful fertilizer as they are rich in nitrogen and contain many beneficial nutrients for soil and crops. Due to biosolids being a by-product of recycled water, they are susceptible to containing the same pathogens and contaminants that can be transferred in the WWTP systems. Antibiotic resistance (AR) is an ever-growing threat on a global scale and is one of the areas of concern for consideration of pathogen spread from WWTPs. Antibiotic resistance bacteria, created through mutation of bacterial plasmids producing antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), have been quantified and studied to help mitigate the risk posed by continued AR spread in the environment. This study aims to produce a comprehensive collection of quantified ARG concentration data in biosolids, as well as producing a QMRA model integrating Monte Carlo distributions to provide groundwork for understanding of the direct dosage and consumption of ARGs to the standard U.S. citizen. The study determined that sul1, sul2, tetM, and tetO are ARGs of high concern in biosolid samples based on current concentration data of biosolid samples. The resulting dose models and gene concentration distributions provide data to support the need to mitigate AR risk presented by agricultural biosolid application.
Date Created
2022-05
Agent

Advancing the Implementation and Adoption of Urine Diversion Systems in Commercial and Institutional Buildings in the United States: A Focus on Control of Urea Hydrolysis

161280-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
This dissertation focused on the implementation of urine diversion systems in commercial and institutional buildings in the United States with a focus on control of the urea hydrolysis reaction. Urine diversion is the process by which urine is separately collected…

This dissertation focused on the implementation of urine diversion systems in commercial and institutional buildings in the United States with a focus on control of the urea hydrolysis reaction. Urine diversion is the process by which urine is separately collected at the source in order to realize system benefits, including water conservation, nutrient recovery, and pharmaceutical removal. Urine diversion systems depend greatly on the functionality of nonwater urinals and urine diverting toilets, which are needed to collect undiluted urine. However, the urea hydrolysis reaction creates conditions that lead to precipitation in the fixtures due to the increase in pH from 6 to 9 as ammonia and bicarbonate are produced. Chapter 2 and Chapter 3 describes the creation and use of a cyber-physical system (CPS) to monitor and control urea hydrolysis in the urinal testbed. Two control logics were used to control urea hydrolysis in realistic restroom conditions. In the experiments, acid was added to inhibit urea hydrolysis during periods of high and low building occupancy. These results were able to show that acid should be added based on the restroom use in order to efficiently inhibit urea hydrolysis. Chapter 4 advanced the results from Chapter 3 by testing the acid addition control logics in a real restroom with the urinal-on-wheels. The results showed that adding acid during periods of high building occupancy equated to the least amount of acid added and allowed for urea hydrolysis inhibition. This study also analyzed the bacterial communities of the collected urine and found that acid addition changed the structure of the bacterial communities. Chapter 5 showed an example of the capabilities of a CPS when implemented in CI buildings. The study used data mining methods to predict chlorine residuals in premise plumbing in a CI green building. The results showed that advance modeling methods were able to model the system better than traditional methods. These results show that CPS technology can be used to illuminate systems and can provide information needed to understand conditions within CI buildings.
Date Created
2021
Agent

Review of the Quantitative Tradeoffs of Using Organic Residuals in Arid Agriculture

158705-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
Water reuse and nutrient recovery are long-standing strategies employed in agricultural systems. This is especially true in dry climates where water is scarce, and soils do not commonly contain the nutrients or organic matter to sustain natural crop growth. Agriculture…

Water reuse and nutrient recovery are long-standing strategies employed in agricultural systems. This is especially true in dry climates where water is scarce, and soils do not commonly contain the nutrients or organic matter to sustain natural crop growth. Agriculture accounts for approximately 70% of all freshwater withdrawals globally. This essential sector of society therefore plays an important role in ensuring water sources are maintained and that the food system can remain resilient to dwindling water resources. The purpose of this research is to quantify the benefits of organic residuals and reclaimed water use in agriculture in arid environments through the development of a systematic review and case study. Data from the systematic review was extracted to be applied to a case study identifying the viability and benefits of organic residuals on arid agriculture. Results show that the organic residuals investigated do have quantitative benefits to agriculture such as improving soil health, reducing the need for conventional fertilizers, and reducing irrigation needs from freshwater sources. Some studies found reclaimed water sources to be of better quality than local freshwater sources due to environmental factors. Biosolids and manure are the most concentrated of the organic residuals, providing nutrient inputs and enhancing long-term soil health. A conceptual model is presented to demonstrate the quantitative benefits of using a reclaimed water source in Pinal County, Arizona on a hypothetical crop of cotton. A goal of the model is to take implied nutrient inputs from reclaimed water sources and quantify them against standard practice of using irrigated groundwater and conventional fertilizers on agricultural operations. Pinal County is an important case study area where farmers are facing cuts to their water resources amid a prolonged drought in the Colorado River Basin. The model shows that a reclaimed water source would be able to offset all freshwater and conventional fertilizer use, but salinity in reclaimed water sources would force a need for additional irrigation in the form of a large leaching fraction. This review combined with the case study demonstrate the potential for nutrient and water reuse, while highlighting potential barriers to address.
Date Created
2020
Agent
Subscribe to Hamilton, Kerry