Exploring Interdisciplinary Space: Interpreting the 40Ar/39Ar Ages of Shocked Ordinary Chondrites, Modeling the Likely Mineralogy of Bulk-Silicate Exoplanets, & Reimagining the Participatory Technology Assessment for NASA Decadal Surveys

193515-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
Solar System history has been shaped by impact processes, such as large-body collisions. The history of impact events is constrained by dating shocked meteorites. Constraining the solar system impact history informs models of solar system formation and can provide insight

Solar System history has been shaped by impact processes, such as large-body collisions. The history of impact events is constrained by dating shocked meteorites. Constraining the solar system impact history informs models of solar system formation and can provide insight into solar system processes around other stars. However, there is a long-standing issues using the 40Ar/39Ar chronometer, the most widely used impact event chronometer, to date heavily impacted meteorites. This issue has resulted in artificially old ages in some heavily shocked samples, up to 7 billion years old, which is far older than the age of the Solar System. In Chapters 2 & 3 I examine four heavily shocked meteorites to elucidate the cause of anomalously old impact ages and recommend best practices for future 40Ar/39Ar impact age interpretations.Over 5,000 exoplanets have been identified using astronomical observations, which has supported new exoplanetary science over the last few decades. Exoplanetary science is still in a nascent stage but progressing quickly. Now more than ever, an interdisciplinary approach can be used to build the foundations of exoplanet sciences. Many geoscience inquiries, such as exoplanet compositions, dynamics of exoplanetary mantles and crusts, and the likelihood of habitability, are just beginning to be addressed. In Chapter 4, I use stellar abundance-derived exoplanet mantle compositions to interrogate the variability in exoplanet compositions and the likelihood of primitive crust formation. The results of this work have significant implications for exoplanet mantle dynamics, melting behavior, and the likelihood of plate tectonics. Lastly, over the last few decades, there have been pushes for science and the innovation that results from it to be conducted responsibly and openly. Moreover, the U.S. federal government has undertaken a transformational path to make federal agency-funded science more open and accessible. One method of increasing open science in science-funding agencies is to make the science and mission prioritization decision process more democratic. The NASA Decadal Surveys are an example of community-driven democratic decision-making in the space sciences and set the science and mission goals for the whole space science community. To support a citizen-centered democratic approach, I develop an expanded model of the participatory technology assessment (pTA) process for use in NASA’s Decadal Surveys.
Date Created
2024
Agent

Composition of Potential Planet Forming Material in Supernova Fallback Disks

166248-Thumbnail Image.png
Description

The first extrasolar planet discovered orbited the millisecond pulsar PSR B1257+12. These so-called "pulsar planets" have proved to be more uncommon than their early discovery might have suggested. The proximity of many known pulsar planets to their host neutron stars

The first extrasolar planet discovered orbited the millisecond pulsar PSR B1257+12. These so-called "pulsar planets" have proved to be more uncommon than their early discovery might have suggested. The proximity of many known pulsar planets to their host neutron stars indicates that they formed post-supernova, possibly from material produced in the supernova. Any pre-existing planets that close would have been obliterated in the supernova. Material from the supernova falls back to an accretion disk around the neutron star analogous to a protoplanetary disk around a protostar. The composition of the supernova thus determines the composition of the planet-forming material. The pulsar planet then forms from collisions between particles within the disk. This research examines the composition of supernova remnants to explore this formation process. Chemical abundances of supernova ejecta were obtained from 3D supernova simulations. The velocities of particles containing silicate-mineral forming elements were filtered to determine what might stay in the system and thus be available for the formation of a fallback disk. The abundances of the remaining particles were compared to characterize the potential composition of such a fallback disk. Overall, the composition was roughly silicate-like, but the rates of mixing versus dust formation could lead to the production of highly exotic minerals.

Date Created
2022-05
Agent

To Be Or Not To B: Meteoritic Implications for the Galactic Environment of Solar System Formation

158294-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
Short-lived radionuclides (SLRs) once present in the solar nebula can be used to probe the Solar System’s galactic formation environment. Isotopic analyses reveal that the first solids formed in the Solar System, calcium- and aluminum-rich inclusions (CAIs) in chondritic meteorites,

Short-lived radionuclides (SLRs) once present in the solar nebula can be used to probe the Solar System’s galactic formation environment. Isotopic analyses reveal that the first solids formed in the Solar System, calcium- and aluminum-rich inclusions (CAIs) in chondritic meteorites, formed with the live SLRs 10Be (t1/2 = 1.4 Ma) and 26Al (t1/2 = 0.7 Ma). Beryllium-10 is produced when high-energy ions, solar energetic particles or galactic cosmic rays (GCRs), spall nuclei in gas or dust. The most likely source of Solar System 10Be is inheritance of GCR-irradiated protosolar molecular cloud material, but only if all CAIs recorded the same initial 10Be abundance. The goal of this dissertation is to assess the homogeneity of 10Be by measuring CAIs for 10Be–10B isotope systematics, correlated to 26Al–26Mg and oxygen isotopes.

I synthesized appropriate standards for secondary ion mass spectrometry (SIMS) measurements of 10Be–10B, necessary for accurate determination of the 10Be/9Be ratio. I then analyzed 32 CAIs for 10Be–10B as well as 6 CAIs for 26Al–26Mg and 5 CAIs for oxygen isotopes within this sample set using SIMS. Previous studies analyzed CAIs primarily from CV3 chondrites, which are known to have experienced thermal metamorphism and aqueous alteration. My work included a variety of CAIs (Type A, B, fine-grained, igneous) from CV3oxidized, CV3reduced, CO3, CR2, and CH/CB chondrites. Finally, after evaluating my data and literature data consistently, I statistically tested whether all CAIs belong to a single 10Be population. I find that the majority (~85%) of the normal (i.e., without large isotopic fractionations or anomalies), 26Al-bearing CAIs recorded a single value, 10Be/9Be = (7.0 ± 0.2) × 10-4. Although 6 CAIs recorded higher or lower values, these are plausibly explained by secondary alteration processes. The galaxy-wide average value of 10Be/9Be from GCR interactions 4.56 billion years ago is predicted to be <2 × 10-4; the value I measured is more than 3 times higher. Because GCRs trace supernovae and star formation, my results suggest a similarly enhanced star formation rate in the molecular cloud within ~1 kpc of the Sun, in the ~15 Ma prior to the Sun’s birth.
Date Created
2020
Agent

The Mineralogy and Chemical Evolution of the Earth’s Deep Mantle

158065-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
The mineralogy of the deep mantle is one of the key factors for the chemical evolution of the Earth. The constituent minerals of the mantle rock control the physical properties of the mantle, which have significant impacts on the large-scale

The mineralogy of the deep mantle is one of the key factors for the chemical evolution of the Earth. The constituent minerals of the mantle rock control the physical properties of the mantle, which have significant impacts on the large-scale processes occurring in the Earth's interior. In my PhD research, I adopted experimental approaches to investigate the mineralogy and the physical properties of the Earth's materials in the deep mantle by using the diamond anvil cells (DACs) combined with in-situ X-ray diffraction techniques.

First, I found that Ca-bearing bridgmanite can be stable in the deeper part of the Earth's lower mantle where temperature is sufficiently high. The dissolution of calcium into bridgmanite can change the physical properties of the mantle, such as compressibility and viscosity. This study suggests a new mineralogical model for the lower mantle, which is composed of the two layers depending on whether calcium dissolves in bridgmanite or forms CaSiO3 perovskite as a separate phase.

Second, I investigated the mineralogy and density of the subducting materials in the Archean at the P-T conditions near 670 km-depth. The experiments suggest that the major phases of Archean volcanic crust is majoritic garnet and ringwoodite in the P-T conditions of the deep transition zone, which become bridgmanite with increasing pressure. The density model showed that Archean volcanic crust would have been denser than the surrounding mantle, promoting sinking into the lower mantle regardless of the style of the transportation in the Archean.

Lastly, I further investigated the mineralogies and densities of the ancient volcanic crusts for the Archean and Proterozoic at the P-T conditions of the lower mantle. The experiments suggest that the mineralogy of the ancient volcanic crusts is composed mostly of bridgmanite, which is systemically denser than the surrounding lower mantle. This implies that the ancient volcanic crusts would have accumulated at the base of the mantle because of their large density and thickness. Therefore, the distinctive chemistry of the ancient volcanic crusts from the surrounding mantle would have given a rise to the chemical heterogeneities in the region for billions of years.
Date Created
2020
Agent

Mineralogy of the Silicon-Rich Mantle: Implications for Mars and Exoplanets

157747-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
With the InSight mission deploying a seismometer , Martian bulk chemical compositional models are more important than ever. Three largely consistent models for the Martian mantle have been suggested over the past two decades. Of these three, two are fairly

With the InSight mission deploying a seismometer , Martian bulk chemical compositional models are more important than ever. Three largely consistent models for the Martian mantle have been suggested over the past two decades. Of these three, two are fairly similar and one is dramatically different. Of these three, the EH70 (Sanloup et al., 1999) models have the systematically lower divalent cation to silicon ratios as compared to the other model, the DW85 (Dreibus and Wanke, 1985) model. However, impact of such a low (Mg+Fe+Ca)/Si ratio on mineralogy has not been experimentally investigated. Measurements have been made of the mineralogy of the EH70 bulk mantle composition (Sanloup et al., 1999)) through in-situ laser-heated diamond anvil cell (LHDAC) and large volume press (LVP). Majorite-garnet (Mj) dominated mineralogy has been observed up to 25 GPa. Bridgmanite (Bm) begins to appear from 25.2 GPa and continues in a mixed phase with Mj up to 27 GPa at which point only Bm and calcium perovskite (CaPv) remain. Akimotoite (Ak) is stable up to 1873 K, higher by ≈300 K compared to numerical calculations (Connolly, 2009). This may result in an Ak layer in the Martian mantle, something missing in Earth’s mantle. The overall ratio of pyroxene to olivine polymorphs by volume is high, approaching pure pyroxene. This agrees with numerical calculations. Additionally, ferropericlase (Fp) is stable at lower temperatures, suggesting a higher dependence on temperature for its stability, something that is different from Perple_X calculations which show a strong dependence on pressure. Furthermore, Mj, which make up a majority of the volume of EH70 mantles, was measured to increase in Fe content as pressure increases. The more oxidizing conditions coupled with the silicon-rich composition resulted in three times higher Fe3+ content in Mj as opposed to a pyrolite model. This increased Fe3+ meant our Mj composition approached that of skiagite (Ski,Fe2+ 3 Fe3+ 2 Si3O12) and this caused Mj to have a very low compressibility of only 152.8 GPa, lower than any other Mj compositions in literature. This result suggests that a mantle with EH70 bulk composition would have lower than predicted seismic wave velocities , lower than Perple_X predicts. The Al content of Mj was also found to suppress the first derivative of compressibility to 4.45, lower than that of Ski100 at 6.7. Such differences compared with pyrolitic composition are important to estimate the velocity profiles and to model the dynamics of the Martian mantle. This dataset of mineralogy and composition can also model terrestrial exoplanetary mantles. Current measurements of stellar abundances show a wide range of compositions, and especially compositions with (Mg+Fe+Ca)/Si ratios approaching 1 (Brewer and Fischer, 2016). This experimental study of EH70 composition can fill-in this gap.
Date Created
2019
Agent

Characterizing Diurnal Density and Temperature Variations in the Martian Atmosphere Using Data/Model Comparisons

132747-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
This project focuses on using Neutral Gas and Ion Mass Spectrometer (NGIMS) density data for carbon dioxide, oxygen, carbon monoxide, and nitrogen during deep dip campaigns 5, 6, and 8. Density profiles obtained from NGIMS were plotted against simulated density

This project focuses on using Neutral Gas and Ion Mass Spectrometer (NGIMS) density data for carbon dioxide, oxygen, carbon monoxide, and nitrogen during deep dip campaigns 5, 6, and 8. Density profiles obtained from NGIMS were plotted against simulated density profiles from the Mars Global Ionosphere-Thermosphere Model (MGITM). Averaged temperature profiles were also plotted for the three deep dip campaigns, using NGIMS data and MGITM output. MGITM was also used as a tool to uncover potential heat balance terms needed to reproduce the mean density and temperature profiles measured by NGIMS.

This method of using NGIMS data as a validation tool for MGITM simulations has been tested previously using dayside data from deep dip campaigns 2 and 8. In those cases, MGITM was able to accurately reproduce the measured density and temperature profiles; however, in the deep dip 5 and 6 campaigns, the results are not quite the same, due to the highly variable nature of the nightside thermosphere. MGITM was able to fairly accurately reproduce the density and temperature profiles for deep dip 5, but the deep dip 6 model output showed unexpected significant variation. The deep dip 6 results reveal possible changes to be made to MGITM to more accurately reflect the observed structure of the nighttime thermosphere. In particular, upgrading the model to incorporate a suitable gravity wave parameterization should better capture the role of global winds in maintaining the nighttime thermospheric structure.

This project reveals that there still exist many unknowns about the structure and dynamics of the night side of the Martian atmosphere, as well as significant diurnal variations in density. Further study is needed to uncover these unknowns and their role in atmospheric mass loss.
Date Created
2019-05
Agent

ExoPlex: a new Python library for detailed modeling of rocky exoplanet internal structure and mineralogy

156961-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
The pace of exoplanet discoveries has rapidly accelerated in the past few decades and the number of planets with measured mass and radius is expected to pick up in the coming years. Many more planets with a size similar to

The pace of exoplanet discoveries has rapidly accelerated in the past few decades and the number of planets with measured mass and radius is expected to pick up in the coming years. Many more planets with a size similar to earth are expected to be found. Currently, software for characterizing rocky planet interiors is lacking. There is no doubt that a planet’s interior plays a key role in determining surface conditions including atmosphere composition and land area. Comparing data with diagrams of mass vs. radius for terrestrial planets provides only a first-order estimate of the internal structure and composition of planets [e.g. Seager et al 2007]. This thesis will present a new Python library, ExoPlex, which has routines to create a forward model of rocky exoplanets between 0.1 and 5 Earth masses. The ExoPlex code offers users the ability to model planets of arbitrary composition of Fe-Si-Mg-Al-Ca-O in addition to a water layer. This is achieved by modeling rocky planets after the earth and other known terrestrial planets. The three distinct layers which make up the Earth's internal structure are: core, mantle, and water. Terrestrial planet cores will be dominated by iron however, like earth, there may be some quantity of light element inclusion which can serve to enhance expected core volumes. In ExoPlex, these light element inclusions are S-Si-O and are included as iron-alloys. Mantles will have a more diverse mineralogy than planet cores. Unlike most other rocky planet models, ExoPlex remains unbiased in its treatment of the mantle in terms of composition. Si-Mg-Al-Ca oxide components are combined by predicting the mantle mineralogy using a Gibbs free energy minimization software package called Perple\_X [Connolly 2009]. By allowing an arbitrary composition, ExoPlex can uniquely model planets using their host star’s composition as an indicator of planet composition. This is a proven technique [Dorn et al 2015] which has not yet been widely utilized, possibly due to the lack of availability of easy to use software. I present a model sensitivity analysis to indicate the most important parameters to constrain in future observing missions. ExoPlex is currently available on PyPI so it may be installed using pip or conda on Mac OS or Linux based operating systems. It requires a specific scripting environment which is explained in the documentation currently stored on the ExoPlex GitHub page.
Date Created
2018
Agent

Investigation into the geodynamics of planetary ice-ocean systems: application to Jupiter's icy moon Europa

155890-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
The Jovian moon Europa's putative subsurface ocean offers one of the closest astrobiological targets for future exploration. It’s geologically young surface with a wide array of surface features aligned with distinct surface composition suggests past/present geophysical activity with implications for

The Jovian moon Europa's putative subsurface ocean offers one of the closest astrobiological targets for future exploration. It’s geologically young surface with a wide array of surface features aligned with distinct surface composition suggests past/present geophysical activity with implications for habitability. In this body of work, I propose a hypothesis for material transport from the ocean towards the surface via a convecting ice-shell. Geodynamical modeling is used to perform numerical experiments on a two-phase water-ice system to test the hypotheses. From these models, I conclude that it is possible for trace oceanic chemistry, entrapped into the newly forming ice at the ice-ocean phase interface, to reach near-surface. This new ice is advected across the ice-shell and towards the surface affirming a dynamical possibility for material transport across the ice-ocean system, of significance to astrobiological prospecting. Next, I use these self-consistent ice-ocean models to study the thickening of ice-shell over time. Europa is subject to the immense gravity field of Jupiter that generates tidal heating within the moon. Analysis of cases with uniform and localized internal tidal heating reveal that as the ice-shell grows from a warm initial ocean, there is an increase in the size of convection cells which causes a dramatic increase in the growth rate of the ice-shell. Addition of sufficient amount of heat also results in an ice-shell at an equilibrium thickness. Localization of tidal heating as a function of viscosity controls the equilibrium thickness. These models are then used to understand how compositional heterogeneity can be created in a growing ice-shell. Impurities (e.g. salts on the surface) that enter the ice-shell get trapped in the thickening ice-shell by freezing. I show the distribution pattern of heterogeneities that can form within the ice-shell at different times. This may be of potential application in identifying the longevity and mobility of brine pockets in Europa's ice-shell which are thought to be potential habitable niches.
Date Created
2017
Agent

Self-Compression of Ceres-like Bodies Composed of Hydrated Silicates

Description
We model the self-compression of homogeneous, undifferentiated, Ceres-like bodies composed of various minerals and mineral-composites: antigorite, brucite, dolomite, lizardite and magnesite, plus mixtures which were the above minerals mixed with ice Ih. All of the modeled clay/ice bodies had a

We model the self-compression of homogeneous, undifferentiated, Ceres-like bodies composed of various minerals and mineral-composites: antigorite, brucite, dolomite, lizardite and magnesite, plus mixtures which were the above minerals mixed with ice Ih. All of the modeled clay/ice bodies had a final radius within 1% of RCeres, an average final density of ~2083 kg m-3 and central pressures of ~133 MPa. The smallest radius was from magnesite, which had a final compressed radius of ~0.88 RCeres, central pressure of ~212 MPa and final density of ~2955 kg m-3. The most significant change in radius was due to the zero-pressure density as the highest densities created the highest force of gravity and produced the smallest radii, yet zero-pressure densities that matched Ceres produced 0.99 RCeres bodies. It was found that the addition of ice, anywhere from 9.1-19.1%, did not affect the body a measurable amount as the inclusion of ice resulted in a lower density creating a lower force of gravity, decreased central pressure and less overall compression. Models that closely resembled Ceres had internal pressures of 133 MPa, which is not enough pressure to induce pore collapse or produce drastic changes due to K and K'. Porosity and the addition of ice in Ceres-like bodies is possible and cannot be ignored when using more complicated modeling techniques. Each mineral and mineral-composite produced unique overall results which allowed us to compare each mineral to Ceres, understand how it has compressed over time and how objects of such a size are affected by compression. Due to the small size, low force of gravity and high bulk moduli of the given minerals, Ceres-like bodies do not compress a considerable amount if they are in fact composed of hydrated silicates.
Date Created
2015-12
Agent

The Diversity of Chemical Composition and the Effects on Stellar Evolution and Planetary Habitability

155766-Thumbnail Image.png
Description
I present a catalog of 1,794 stellar evolution models for solar-type and low-mass stars, which is intended to help characterize real host-stars of interest during the ongoing search for potentially habitable exoplanets. The main grid is composed of 904 tracks,

I present a catalog of 1,794 stellar evolution models for solar-type and low-mass stars, which is intended to help characterize real host-stars of interest during the ongoing search for potentially habitable exoplanets. The main grid is composed of 904 tracks, for 0.5-1.2 M_sol at scaled metallicity values of 0.1-1.5 Z_sol and specific elemental abundance ratio values of 0.44-2.28 O/Fe_sol, 0.58-1.72 C/Fe_sol, 0.54-1.84 Mg/Fe_sol, and 0.5-2.0 Ne/Fe_sol. The catalog includes a small grid of late stage evolutionary tracks (25 models), as well as a grid of M-dwarf stars for 0.1-0.45 M_sol (856 models). The time-dependent habitable zone evolution is calculated for each track, and is strongly dependent on stellar mass, effective temperature, and luminosity parameterizations. I have also developed a subroutine for the stellar evolution code TYCHO that implements a minimalist coupled model for estimating changes in the stellar X-ray luminosity, mass loss, rotational velocity, and magnetic activity over time; to test the utility of the updated code, I created a small grid (9 models) for solar-mass stars, with variations in rotational velocity and scaled metallicity. Including this kind of information in the catalog will ultimately allow for a more robust consideration of the long-term conditions that orbiting planets may experience.

In order to gauge the true habitability potential of a given planetary system, it is extremely important to characterize the host-star's mass, specific chemical composition, and thus the timescale over which the star will evolve. It is also necessary to assess the likelihood that a planet found in the "instantaneous" habitable zone has actually had sufficient time to become "detectably" habitable. This catalog provides accurate stellar evolution predictions for a large collection of theoretical host-stars; the models are of particular utility in that they represent the real variation in stellar parameters that have been observed in nearby stars.
Date Created
2017
Agent