Influences of Vegan Status on Protein Intake, Strength, and Bone Mineral Density

Plant-based eaters are known to reap nutritional benefits due to their dietchoice, but it is important to evaluate dietary differences that may put them at a disadvantage compared to omnivores. Stark differences exist in daily intakes of protein between vegans and omnivores, which may lead to several risks including decreased strength and bone density. The purpose of this study was to analyze the differences in protein intake, lean mass, strength, and bone density in vegans versus omnivores in order to support the argument for an increased recommended daily allowance (RDA) for protein for plant-based eaters. Participants in this study were assigned to groups based on omnivorous (n = 25) or vegan (n = 19) dietary pattern. Nineteen matched pairs were created based on age and BMI. Data was collected at a single lab visit and included health history and physical activity readiness questionnaires, 24-hr food recall, and anthropometric measures. Bone mineral density (BMD) was measured using DEXA and strength was assessed using hand and Biodex dynamometers. Statistical analyses were conducted using independent samples t-tests and Pearson’s correlation tests to evaluate differences in body composition, bone density, strength, and dietary intake between the two groups with significance set at p.05. Differences were seen in daily calorie (p=.007), protein (p<.001), fat (p<.001), and fiber (p=.009) intake. Lean mass (p=.282) and bone density (p=.651) were not different between groups, but lower body strength was different (p=.008). There was a correlation between lower body strength and protein intake (p<.001), and lean mass was correlated with lower body strength (p<.001), grip strength (p<.001), and bone density (p<.001), but not i LBM (p=0.158). Correlations were also observed between BMD and lower body strength (p=.004). These data suggest that there is a significant difference between protein intake in vegans versus omnivores, which appears to have a positive association with strength. BMD also has a positive association with strength as well as lean mass. Cumulatively, the results suggest that it may be beneficial for vegans to increase daily protein intake.