Effects of Vortex Generation on the Fuel Efficiency and Engine Load of a Common Car

This experiment investigated the effects of different vortex generator sizes and configurations on the induced drag of a 2006 Honda Accord, with comparisons to a control test. Tuft tests were carried out prior to any data collection. The tufts were placed along the roof and rear window of the vehicle for each of the five vortex generator types. Video was taken of the tufts for each set of vortex generators, allowing a visual comparison of the flow characteristics with comparison to the control. Out of the four vortex generators tested, the two that yielded the most substantial change in the flow characteristics were utilized. The data collection was conducted utilizing the two sets of vortex generators, one large and one small, placed in three different locations along the roof of the vehicle. Over a course of four trials of data collection, each vortex generator size and configuration was tested two times along a stretch of Interstate 60, with each data set consisting of five minutes heading east, followed by five minutes heading west. Several experimental parameters were collected using an OBD II Bluetooth Adaptor, which were logged using the software compatible with the adaptor. This data was parsed and analyzed in Microsoft Excel and MATLAB. Utilizing an Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) analytical scheme, the data was generalized to account for terrain changes, steady state speed fluctuations, and weather changes per night. Overall, upon analysis of the data, the vortex generators showed little-to-no benefit to either the fuel efficiency or engine load experienced by the vehicle during the duration of the experiment. This result, while unexpected, is substantial as it shows that the expenditure of purchasing these vortex generators for this make and model of vehicle, and potentially other similar vehicles, is unnecessary as it produces no meaningful benefit.