To Explode or to Implode: How Cells Decide Between Apoptosis and Necroptosis Following Viral or Chemical Stress

Cell death is a powerful tool through which organisms can inhibit the spread of viruses by preventing their replication. In this work, I used viral and chemical stressors to elucidate the mechanisms by which one anti-viral system might be activated over another, focusing on the programmable death pathway necroptosis and Protein Kinase R (PKR). PKR can detect viral dsRNA and trigger antiviral effects such as cessation of translation and induction of programmed death. Necroptosis is a rapid cellular death that can be induced via sensors such as DNA-dependent activator of IFN-regulatory factors (DAI), also known as Z-DNA-binding protein 1 (ZBP1). DAI contains a Z-form nucleic acid (ZNA) binding domain. E3, the primary vaccinia virus (VACV) interferon resistance protein, contains a similar domain in its amino terminus. We have previously reported this domain to be necessary for the inhibition of both PKR activation and DAI/ZBP1-mediated necroptosis.

Monkeypox virus is a reemerging human pathogen. Despite a partial amino-terminal deletion in its E3 homolog, it does not activate PKR. In chapter 2, I show that MPXV produces less dsRNA than VACV, which could explain how the virus avoids activating PKR.

The amino-terminus of vaccinia is associated with ZNA binding, inhibition of PKR, and inhibition of necroptosis. To determine the roles of PKR inhibition and ZNA binding in necroptosis inhibition, I characterized the VACV mutants Za(ADAR1)-E3, which binds ZNA but does not inhibit PKR, and E3:Y48A, which cannot bind ZNA. I found that while Za(ADAR1)-E3 fails to induce necroptosis, E3:Y48A does not activate PKR but does induce necroptosis. This suggests that Z-form nucleic acid binding is not necessary for vaccinia E3-mediated inhibition of PKR, nor is the inhibition of PKR sufficient for the inhibition of necroptosis.

Finally, all known ZNA-binding proteins have immune functions and home to stress granules. I asked if stress granule formation alone could lead to necroptosis. I found that in L929 cells sodium arsenite, a known inducer of stress granules, could trigger DAI-dependent necroptosis. This suggests that DAI/ZBP1 is not necessarily a sensor of viral ligands but perhaps is a sensor of stress signals brought about by infection.